From Fluid to Felony: When Missed Hearing Loss Becomes a Prison Sentence

Otitis media (ear infections) and minimal hearing loss are often dismissed as mild or temporary.
But for children growing up in poverty, these conditions are neither harmless nor short-lived.
They can silently reroute a child’s development—from speech delay, to reading failure, to incarceration.

This post combines research and story to show how unrecognized hearing loss becomes a gateway to injustice.

Read the story. Then stay for the facts.

I Wasn’t Born Broken. You Just Waited Too Long.

This isn’t a true story, not in the memoir sense. It’s a composite narrative—a first-person account of a child whose life was shaped by something we often dismiss as “mild”: chronic ear infections.

I’m telling it in the voice of “I,” because statistics don’t sting.
Stories do.

When you read, “X% of children with recurrent otitis media,” it’s easy to nod and move on.
But when you walk inside the silence, frustration, confusion, and missed opportunities of just one child, you start to ask:

How many more are slipping through the cracks right now?

This narrative is a thought experiment.
It’s a challenge to our medical, educational, and social systems.
It’s also a direct invitation to innovators:

You talk about enhancing human potential.
But what if the next frontier isn’t augmentation?
What if it’s prevention?

What if we could stop the most common sensory-language disconnections from ever becoming disorders?

What if we could keep kids off IEPs, out of prisons, and inside communities—by fixing the signal before the wiring goes wrong?

This story is fiction.
The crisis it depicts is not.

Read it. Share it.

And let’s stop losing kids to problems we already know how to prevent.

[]

What the Research Shows

“Children with a history of otitis media before age three scored more than one year below grade level in reading at ages eight to ten.” (Kidig & Richards, 2000)

Children with otitis media show dyslexia-like phonological issues, but from degraded input, not true dyslexia. (Carroll & Breadmore, 2018)

Zinc supplements reduced average AOM episodes by more than 1 per child. (Gulani, 2012 – Cochrane Review)

Vitamin D deficiency increased otitis media risk by 66%.(Restuti et al., 2024)

What Happens Next

“In a Louisiana study, 47% of inmates were found to have dyslexia, and 87% had dropped out by 9th grade.”
(Reynolds et al., 1990)

Mother Jones (2019) reported that half of Texas inmates were likely dyslexic, and two-thirds struggled with reading comprehension.

Succeed With Dyslexia (2022) cited that 80% of Texas inmates had low literacy, and 50% were likely dyslexic.

Cassidy et al. (2021) found 47% of tested inmates had dyslexia, almost identical to the 1990 findings.

Bureau of Justice Statistics (2016) showed:

14.1% of prisoners report a learning disability
24.4% report ADHD—both often tied to early language access failure

What This Means

Many kids aren’t broken.
They’re unheard.

We are losing children not because they lack potential, but because we failed to protect their access to sound, language, and meaning during the most crucial years of development.

Stop waiting.
Stop mislabeling.
Stop assuming mild means harmless.

Fix the signal before we blame the brain.

_____

William’s (Composite) Story:

The fluid started early.

By six months, something was off. I cried more than other babies—especially at night, especially after lying down.
Sometimes there were fevers. Sometimes just congestion. Sometimes I’d wake up screaming, always tugging at my ears, especially the left one.

The pediatrician said it was normal. Said it was teething, or a cold, or allergies.
“You’ve just put him in daycare,” they said. “This is what happens.”

So they treated it like childhood.
Round after round of antibiotics.
Each time, the crying eased.
Then it came back.

Then came the plane ride.

I screamed during descent. Clawed at my ears. Afterward, my left ear stayed jammed. It didn’t pop for a week.

My mom brought me back in. The pediatrician said, “Let’s try one more round. It’ll clear up on its own.”

It didn’t.

It took months to see a specialist.
The ENT checked the pressure: negative in one ear, fluid in the other.
“He needs tubes,” they said. “He needed them a while ago.”

I was two.

I started talking late. Mostly sounds.

When I finally said “mama,” my mom cried. But not many more words came.

I pointed at things. Pulled her by the hand. Made noises, not words.
She read. She sang. She talked all the time. She did everything right.

My dad tried too. His voice was lower, deeper. Sometimes I heard him a little better.

But the quick parts of speech—the consonants, the sharp bits—never made it in.

And if words don’t come in clear, they can’t come out.

Preschool came.

They told my parents I was just a little behind.
“Boys talk slow.”
“Give it time.”

So they waited.
Because that’s what they were told.

I didn’t follow directions.
Not because I didn’t care.
Because I didn’t catch all the words.

They’d say “Put your lunchbox away,” and by the time I realized they were talking to me, it was already too late.

So they said I had bad behavior.

I got up and wandered.
Not to be disruptive.
But because my ears were off balance.
My body didn’t trust where it was in space.

I stumbled a lot.
Fell over nothing.
They called me clumsy.

On the playground, I’d lose track of people.
If someone called my name, I’d turn the wrong way.
Sound came from everywhere and nowhere.

At the grocery store, I’d wander too far.
I couldn’t keep track of my mom’s voice.
Even when she shouted, I’d go the wrong way until security brought me back.

Then the other kids started learning letters.

I wanted to.
I tried hard.
But they wouldn’t stick.

I’d forget them the next day.
I couldn’t match sounds to shapes.
“B” looked like “P,” or I said nothing.

It wasn’t because I was dumb.
It was because I didn’t hear clearly enough to remember them.

And my eyes wouldn’t stay still.
My brain was used to uneven input.
That messes with how your eyes move across a page.
The lines blurred. Jumped. Shifted.

But sometimes, when it was quiet, with just one teacher, and my hearing was better—
I could get it.
I could keep up.
I could even shine.

But it never lasted long enough to build on.

I didn’t have enough words to learn new words.
How do you learn “confuse” or “probably” if you never hear them clearly in a sentence?

I heard part of a sentence. I guessed.
Guessed what the teacher wanted.
Copied other kids.

But it wasn’t enough.

I missed what people said.
All the time.

When I didn’t do what they asked, they said “behavior.”
They told me to try harder. To pay attention. To stop being difficult.

But I wasn’t difficult.
I was surviving in a classroom that was too fast and too loud.

I got angry.
Frustrated.
Ashamed.

I couldn’t say “I don’t get it.”
So I said, “I don’t care.”

I avoided work.
Blew up when I didn’t know what was coming next.

They called it ODD.
Talked about PDA.
Said I was defiant.
That I needed structure.

Structure only helped if it slowed things down enough for my brain to hear the message.

Nobody did that.

I didn’t play sports. I was too clumsy.
My handwriting was awful.
Not because I didn’t try.
But because my eyes couldn’t stay steady.

Maybe my gut never healed either.
Too many antibiotics.
I had food sensitivities.
My mood swung hard.
Cried easily. Got mad fast.

Nobody put it all together.

It didn’t just affect my ears.
It changed everything.

School. Friendships. Reading. Self-esteem.
All bent around a signal that never came through right.

Even as an adult, I was still on medication.
I needed it. I was used to it.

I was still labeled with ADHD.
Still anxious. Still overwhelmed.
Still trying to calm a nervous system that never felt safe.

I apprenticed at a mechanic shop.
I was good at it. My hands were better than my words.

But one day, I didn’t follow the manual.
Not because I didn’t care.
But because reading dense instructions was always hard for me.

I made a mistake—one I couldn’t afford to fix.
And I didn’t know how to explain it.
My boss said I wasn’t taking responsibility.
So they let me go.

I had no income.
My rent was due.
And my social skills weren’t strong enough to ask for help.

So when someone said,
“Want to sell your meds? You could make rent,”
I didn’t think twice.
I didn’t look up the laws.
I didn’t really understand the risk.
I didn’t worry about if it could hurt anyone.
It never hurt me.

That’s how I got a felony.

Not because I was dangerous.
Not because I meant harm.
But because no one ever taught me how to navigate a world that wasn’t built for me.

I’m not a bad person.
I’m not a danger.
I’m not a diagnosis.

I’m someone who never got a clean signal when it mattered.

I wasn’t born broken.
I was born with two working ears, a curious brain, and a body ready to learn.

But the fluid came.
And the signals got scrambled.
And no one fixed it in time.

You caused the disability.

Not in one moment.
But in all the little ones.

“It’s just an ear infection.”
“He’ll catch up.”
“Give it time.”
“Use your words.”

And I would’ve—if I had ever heard them clearly enough to understand.

You could’ve stepped in.

You could’ve given me visual language.
You could’ve boosted the sound.
You could’ve protected me from loud noise.
You could’ve told my teachers what to watch for.

You could’ve treated my hearing like a broken bone.

With urgency.
With care.
Like it mattered.

Because it did matter.

I was a child trying to understand the world.

And you gave me silence, confusion, and delay.

This is what happens when we mistake “temporary” for harmless.
When we treat mild hearing loss like it’s not worth fixing.
When we forget that language doesn’t wait.

And neither does the brain.

This is not a TRUE story, but it might as well be. Read the facts above.

References

Bess, F. H., & Hornsby, B. W. Y. (2014). Mild hearing loss in children: Revisited. Perspectives on Hearing and Hearing Disorders in Childhood, 24(1), 10–16.

Carroll, J. M., & Breadmore, H. L. (2018). Not all phonological awareness deficits are created equal: Evidence from a comparison between children with otitis media and poor readers. Developmental Science, 21(3), e12588.

Cassidy, L., Reggio, K., Shaywitz, B. A., Holahan, J. M., & Shaywitz, S. E. (2021). Dyslexia in incarcerated men and women: A new perspective on reading disability in the prison population. Journal of Correctional Education, 72(2), 61–81.

Castagno, L. A., & Lavinsky, L. (2002). Otitis media in children: Seasonal changes and socioeconomic level. International Journal of Pediatric Otorhinolaryngology, 62(2), 129–134.

Chadha, S. K., Sayal, A., Malhotra, V., & Agarwal, A. K. (2006). Comparative evaluation of ear diseases in children of higher versus lower socioeconomic strata. Journal of Laryngology and Otology, 120(1), 16–19.

Gulani, A. (2012). Zinc supplements for preventing otitis media. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews, 11, CD006639.

Kindig, J. S., & Richards, H. C. (2000). Otitis media: Precursor of delayed reading. Journal of Pediatric Psychology, 25(1), 15–18.

Mother Jones. (2019, April 30). People in prison are way more likely to have dyslexia. The justice system sets them up to fail. https://www.motherjones.com/crime-justice/2019/04/prison-dyslexia-education-literacy-reading-special-ed/

Reynolds, C. R., Shaywitz, B. A., Fletcher, J. M., & Shaywitz, S. E. (1990). Incarceration and reading disabilities: A national perspective. Journal of Learning Disabilities, 23(6), 346–352.

Restuti, R. D., Safitri, E. D., Wulansari, R., Rini, I. A., & Maharani, D. A. (2024). Association between vitamin D deficiency and otitis media with effusion in children: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Paediatrica Indonesiana, 64(5), 419–429.

Succeed With Dyslexia. (2022, February 7). Low literacy in prisons: What does it mean? https://www.succeedwithdyslexia.org/blog/low-literacy-in-prisons-what-does-it-mean

U.S. Bureau of Justice Statistics. (2017). Disabilities reported by prisoners, 2016. Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Justice.